How I Got the Algorithm to Love My Content Again (Without Burning Out)
Let’s talk about the content hamster wheel — the one where you're constantly posting, creating, brainstorming, and still… feeling like you’re invisible online.
I’ve been there.
As someone who creates content for a living and helps others do the same, I know how frustrating it feels to pour effort into Reels, write thoughtful captions, follow every trend — and still get low reach, low engagement, and zero momentum.
It felt like the algorithm forgot I existed. Worse… it made me start questioning if the work was even worth it.
But what changed everything for me was a strategy I now teach to all of my clients and students. I call it The Rule of 3 — and it helped me grow my engagement, reconnect with my audience, and finally feel in control of my content again.
What Is the Rule of 3?
The Rule of 3 is a simple but powerful Instagram Reels strategy where you take one content idea and repurpose it into three distinct types of Reels:
1. Trending Audio Reel (for reach)
This is the Reel that gets eyes on your content.
Use a trending sound (ideally under 10k uses) and pair it with a short text hook over video.
These Reels tap into the Explore Page algorithm and help you reach new people quickly.
Example:
On-screen text: “I used to hate selling in Stories… until I did this 👇”
You pair it with a trending audio that matches the mood and energy of your message.
2. Talking Head Reel (for authority)
This is the Reel that builds trust and credibility.
You face the camera and share one clear tip, story, or insight — short and to the point (keep it under 30 seconds for best performance).
Example:
“Here’s how I sell in my Instagram Stories without sounding pushy: I imagine I’m talking to one friend who truly needs what I offer. I keep it real, casual, and clear.”
This Reel is for your existing or warm audience who wants to learn from you directly.
3. Hook + Caption Reel (for engagement & conversion)
This is the Reel that drives shares, saves, and action.
You use a compelling on-screen hook with music, but keep the real value in the caption.
Example:
On-screen: “3 ways I sell in Stories without sounding salesy”
Caption: ✅ Tip 1, ✅ Tip 2, ✅ Tip 3, plus a CTA like “DM me the word STORIES and I’ll send you a free example.”
This format connects with people who like to read, save tips, and take action after consuming.
Why the Rule of 3 Works
Because not everyone consumes content the same way.
Some people need the hook.
Others want to see your face.
Some prefer to read and digest on their own time.
The Rule of 3 allows you to meet every type of audience member where they’re at without creating brand new content every single day.
More variety = more visibility.
More consistency = more trust.
More strategy = more sales.
How I Use This Strategy Every Week
Here's how I implement The Rule of 3 in my own business:
🧠 I start with one idea (usually a pain point or question my audience is asking)
📹 I batch the three Reel types back-to-back in one sitting
🗓️ I post them throughout the week, 1–2 days apart
That’s it. No guesswork. No burnout. Just a repeatable system that works.
If you’re someone who only posts 3x/week, this can be your entire Reels strategy.
Want My Rule of 3 System + 30 Days of Reels Ideas?
I’ve bundled up my exact process into a plug-and-play system called the Instagram Growth Starter Pack.
Inside, you’ll get:
A breakdown of the Rule of 3 strategy
30 days of Reels prompts (including hooks, captions, and audio ideas)
My favorite growth tips for 2024 and beyond
🎁 Click here to grab the Starter Pack now
It’s time to stop overthinking and start showing up with a strategy that works.
If the algorithm has been ignoring your content, don’t take it personally just take control.
The Rule of 3 helped me fall back in love with content.
It might do the same for you.
– Katelyn Rhoades
Founder, enfluence Marketing Studio
Host, Call Her Creator
Listen to this full episode on Apple
Listen to this full episode on Spotify
